Lexsure e-ROT

Rights of Access · Report on Title scenario

Who is obliged to contribute to maintaining the access?

In theory whoever the deed says. In practice often nobody, because an obligation to pay is a positive covenant and positive covenants do not generally bind later owners of freehold land. The person who originally promised to contribute stays bound for ever; the person who bought their house in 2011 may not be bound at all.

From the e-ROT archive

This scenario is drawn from Report on Title material dealing with this specific circumstance.

Lexsure Report on Title paragraph: Property is subject to a right of way · See the wording

Why the obligation leaks away

Covenants come in two kinds. A restrictive covenant — do not build, do not use for trade — can bind later owners of the burdened land. A positive covenant — pay, repair, contribute — generally does not.

An obligation to contribute to the cost of maintaining a track is a positive covenant, so it does not run with the land. The original covenantor remains contractually bound for ever, which is of limited use once they have sold and moved on.

The result is a deed that reads as though everyone shares the cost and a road where nobody does.

Already bought, and nobody will contribute?

If a shared access is falling apart and the obligations cannot be enforced, what was reported to you about them during the purchase is a reasonable place to start.

Find out what should have been explained → WhenIBought.com

How it is supposed to be held together

Where developers care about this, they build a chain: each buyer covenants directly with the party entitled, and a restriction on the title prevents the next sale from being registered until the new owner does the same. That converts an unenforceable obligation into an enforceable one, one sale at a time.

Where the chain was never set up, or has been broken by a sale that slipped through, the obligation is likely to be unenforceable against the people who are actually there.

Your conveyancer can see whether a restriction exists on the neighbouring titles, and whether the chain has held.

What to do about it in practice

Find out what the arrangement actually is on the ground. Who has paid for work on the track in the past ten years, and on what basis — a formal obligation, an informal arrangement, or one exasperated neighbour.

Ask what state the access is in and what it would cost to put right, because if the obligation is unenforceable the cost will fall where it lands rather than where the deed says.

Where a track is important to the property — the only vehicular access, for example — the absence of an enforceable maintenance obligation is a real cost of ownership and worth factoring into the price rather than discovering afterwards.

From the e-ROT archive

Report on Title paragraph

Property is subject to a right of way

Archive Lexsure e-ROTScope Contribution to maintenanceWord count 104Published July 2019

A positive covenant generally imposes an obligation to carry out some positive action in relation to land or requires expenditure of money. In contrast, a restrictive covenant restricts the use and enjoyment of the land. The burden (the obligation to observe a covenant) does not generally bind successors in title of freehold land where a covenant is positive in nature, but it may do so if the covenant is negative. A covenant to repair or contribute to the cost of repair is a positive covenant and will not run with the land. It will not be enforceable once the original covenantor transfers its interest. …

Historic wording — DO NOT USE on a current transaction. Published in July 2019 and reproduced exactly, including the double spaces between sentences. It states a general principle; whether it applies to a particular covenant depends on that covenant.

Dealing with this on a current conveyancing matter?

Current Report on Title paragraph

Do not rely on wording copied or saved from this page. Get the current wording dealing with this scenario.

View current paragraph →

ROT Notification Service

Keep relevant ROT wording under review as Lexsure issues updates.

View Notification Service →

e-ROT Generator

Use Lexsure’s full Report on Title system.

Explore e-ROT Generator →